2015 North American Beer Awards

Silver- The Keeper Biere de Garde

2014- North American Beer Awards

Gold- Rob Moore Abbey Ale
Gold- The Golden Boy
Silver- Biere de Mars 2014
Bronze- Frambeaux
Bronze- Switchyard Scottish Ale

2013 North American Beer Awards

Silver- Smokehouse Lager
Silver- Biere de Mars
Bronze- Saison de Carter
Bronze- Eldorado ESB
2011- Great American Beer Fest
Silver Medal - Blackened CDA

2011-North American Beer Awards

Bronze- Double Imperial Irish Red Ale
2009- Carter's Brewing won at North American Beer Awards!
Silver - Rob Moore Abbey Ale
Bronze - Black Magic Porter
Bronze - Saison de Carter
Bronze - Amarillo Pale Ale